Loading... Please wait...


Olive Oil Buttercream - Light & Delicious

Posted by

This “buttercream” has a secret--there’s actually no butter at all contained in the recipe! Instead, it gets its rich, smooth flavor from the addition of Extra Virgin Olive Oil.

  • 4 pasteurized egg whites
  • ⅛ teaspoon salt
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • ¾ cup granulated sugar
  • ¼ cup (4 tablespoons) Extra Virgin olive oil, divided
  1. In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment, whisk the egg whites on high speed until they hold soft peaks.
  2. Pause the mixer. Add the salt, vanilla, and granulated’ sugar. Stir on low speed until everything is moistened (no sugar snowstorms!), then increase the speed to high. Continue whisking until the mixture holds very firm peaks.
  3. Remove the bowl from the mixer. Fold in the olive oil, one tablespoon at a time, mixing very gently. Keep an eye on the consistency as you add the olive oil--you may prefer not to add all 4 tablespoons, depending on your desired consistency, and on the humidity in your kitchen.
  4. Your olive oil “buttercream” is ready! Use it right away to ensure the best consistency.

Original recipe from CakeSpy.

View Comments

Karie Anne's Italian Ice & Custard is coming to Love at First Bite!!

We are really excited to launch Karie Anne's Italian Ice & Custard is coming to Love at First Bite on May 30, 2016! Families travel for miles for Karie Anne's and we are thrilled to provide this gourmet custard and ice to our customers in the comfort of our store. 

Read More »

Why Our Olive Oil is a BIG DEAL!

If you've tasted our olive oil, you know it's nothing like what you can find at a grocery store. Our supplier has a really amazing story that we want to share with all of you: Veronica Foods Company was founded in New York City in 1924 by Italian immigrant Salvatore Esposito. The Delizia olive oil brand [...]

Read More »

Love at First Bite: Feature Story from The Mike Hicks Realty Group

LOVE AT FIRST BITE: A LOCAL BUSINESS SPOTLIGHTPosted by Mike Hicks on Tuesday, January 19th, 2016 at 9:10am at http://www.idahofallsproperty.com/blog/local-business-spotlight.html.Love at First Bite. Don't you just adore that name? You just know that whatever is inside, it must be positively scrumptious! This adorable little shop is the brain child of Juli Richards, and is truly one [...]

Read More »

The Most Wonderful Time of the Year

Now that Thanksgiving is over and we've moved into the final weeks of the holiday season, we want to extend our gratitude to our amazing customers who have supported our small family-owned business for so many years. We hope that you find Love at First Bite Mercantile a place where you and your family feel comfortable [...]

Read More »

Mother's Day Menu Ideas

Mother's Day is the special day that we honor mother's around the world. And although I know that many of try to honor the mothers in our life every day, it's nice to have a dedicated day where mom's get a little spoiled (and hopefully, get shown a lot of appreciation!). Love at First Bite has [...]

Read More »

St. Patrick's Day Fun!

We have loads of goodies to make every day in March a rainbow of fun!From green pasta, to cute decor, we know how to put the ROCK in Shamrock! Check out our store - located at 901 Pier View Drive in Snake River Landing in Idaho Falls - for all of your holiday needs. Looking to get [...]

Read More »

(Wedding) LOVE is in the Air!

There is nothing better than wedding season for the staff at Love at First Bite! We love to work with brides to ensure that every detail of their dream day is perfect. From customizing frosting and flavors for cupcakes, cookies, and truffles to assisting the bride in choosing decor and gifts for the wedding, we [...]

Read More »

Ready for Black Friday?

We are open regular hours on Black Friday (10 a.m. - 6 p.m.) and are truly excited to offer you the finest home decor, treats, and gourmet food items at spectacular prices! Love at First Bite Mercantile truly has gifts for everyone. Need something for the man in your life? From specialty foods (like salami and [...]

Read More »

Halloween & Fall Decor - NEW ITEMS

Hello friends!We have incredible new Fall and Halloween decor in stock that will help you reflect your personality within your home. From garlands to decorative pillows and signs, we have the right balance of classy but frightful accessories! For a limited time, we are offering 20% off your favorite Fall or Halloween decor item - [...]

Read More »


About Us

Love at First Bite Mercantile
901 Pier View Drive #101
Idaho Falls, ID 83402

Mon-Fri 10am - 6pm
Sat 10am - 5pm

Recent Updates